PositioningPlaybook
Before you pick a channel, pick a reason to win.
A practical positioning exercise to clarify who your product is for, what it replaces, and why someone should choose it.
It’s tempting to start go-to-market with a channel. Launch on a community. Publish on LinkedIn. Try an outbound sequence. Run a few ads.
Those choices matter. But a channel distributes your argument. It doesn’t make the argument for you.
If you can’t explain why a particular person should choose your product over what they already do, more distribution can simply deliver that uncertainty to more people. Before you decide where to show up, write down your reason to win.
Start with the situation, not the persona
“Small businesses” is a market description. It doesn’t tell you much about a buying decision. A situation gets you closer: a small agency that has just lost track of client approvals across three tools, or a finance lead preparing for a first audit.
Describe the moment that makes your product relevant:
- What happened just before someone started looking for help?
- What are they trying to finish, fix, or avoid?
- What gets harder if they do nothing?
- Who feels the problem, and who can decide to change something?
Keep the first version narrow enough that you can recognize a real person in it. You can widen the audience later. Right now, you need a useful hypothesis.
Name the actual alternative
Your competitive alternative isn’t always another product in the same category. It might be a spreadsheet, an assistant, a weekly meeting, or accepting the inconvenience.
Ask what your target customer would do if your product disappeared tomorrow. That answer defines the comparison you need to make.
For an illustrative approval tool, the alternative might be email threads and a shared document. “We have a better dashboard” is a feature comparison. “Everyone can see exactly which version the client approved” connects the difference to the work.
Write down the alternative’s strengths too. A spreadsheet is familiar. Email requires no new training. An existing tool may already be paid for. Your argument has to account for these advantages.
Connect a difference to a consequence
List three things your product does differently. Then complete this chain for each one:
Difference → practical consequence → customer value.
For example:
| Difference | Practical consequence | Why the customer cares |
|---|---|---|
| Approvals are attached to a specific version | The team can identify what was agreed | Less rework caused by version confusion |
| Feedback stays beside the asset | People don’t have to reconstruct an email thread | A clearer handoff between reviewer and maker |
| The next reviewer is visible | The team knows who needs to act | Less time spent asking for a status update |
These are illustrative claims, not evidence about a particular product. For your own product, only keep claims you can demonstrate.
Write one positioning sentence
Use a sentence to force a choice, rather than to produce final homepage copy:
For [people in a specific situation], [product] is a [recognizable category] that helps them [valuable outcome], because [demonstrable difference].
If the sentence contains several audiences, unrelated outcomes, or a list of six differentiators, cut it down. The exercise is doing its job when you have to decide what matters most.
Then write a second sentence: “This is a weaker fit when…”
That boundary is useful. It makes qualification easier and gives your message a shape. A product that claims to be the best choice for every situation gives a buyer little help with their particular decision.
Test comprehension before conversion
Show the argument to a few people who resemble the audience. Ask them to explain it back in their own words. Avoid asking whether they “like” it.
Useful questions include:
- Who does this seem to be for?
- What problem would you use it to solve?
- What would you compare it with?
- What would you need to believe or verify before trying it?
You are looking for misunderstandings, unfamiliar language, and missing proof. This isn’t a statistically representative experiment. It’s a way to catch obvious confusion before spending more to distribute it.
Make the next move small
Put the audience, situation, alternative, valuable difference, and necessary proof on one page. Use that page to choose your first channel and shape the message you take there.
The goal isn’t a perfect positioning document. It’s a clear enough argument to put in front of the right people—and a concrete way to learn what to change next.
A field note from Switchcase. Clear thinking for your next move.
Follow the field notes with RSS